Joint Statement Brighton and Hove Community Land Trust (BHCLT) and Coldean Community Organisation (CCOrg) site 21a and 21c

The Site:

The site 21a was identified in the Urban Fringe review as having potential for housing and this was confirmed in the city plan.  The site was put on the community-led housing pathway.

How we got together:

CCOrg was established following a community organising process, supported by BHCLT.

A formal partnership was established between CCOrg and BHCLT to develop proposals for community-led housing (CLH) on the site following the successful bid to Homes England fronted by BHCLT, and agreed on the basis that any proposals developed would respond to the needs and aspirations of the Coldean community and have a positive impact the wider city.

What we did

We formed a steering group for the project with representation from both organisations to oversee the project from team recruitment to pre-planning with 2 design options.

A suite of investigations and surveys was commissioned.

We submitted a proposal for pre-app planning advice at the end of July 2020 and received detailed feedback on 12th November 2020 (with all outstanding comments received by February 2021).

 Why we are stopping working together

We have agreed to terminate the partnership due to a divergence of visions and a breakdown of trust between the organisations. These have been clarified during conversations between BHCLT and CCOrg following the response to the planning pre-app for 47-59 homes on the site. We have held a series of regular meetings in an attempt to resolve these differences but in the end, it has become clear that, despite all our best efforts, we are unable to negotiate the difference in positions to continue the partnership.

BHCLT perspective BHCLT has a ‘housing first’ approach and wants to maximise the use of housing on the site within the context of the landscape and ecology. BHCLT sees Coldean site 21a as the only site currently with the potential of achieving a large-scale CLH project.  BHCLT sees the pre-app submitted as sensitive to the site’s ecology and landscape but does not have the appetite to take it forward without the agreement and support of the local community organisation. On this basis, BHCLT is not going to be directly involved in taking forward this site in the foreseeable future.

CCOrg perspective CCOrg has an ‘ecology first’ approach that seeks to continue its pledge to the community to explore whether housing could sit within the context of land stewardship. The project was pushed to consider higher density than identified on the Urban Fringe Assessment, and there is concern that the resulting designs are therefore not appropriate within the context of such a sensitive Urban Fringe site, due to the impact on pre-existing wildlife & woodland.

The ecologists report that there are areas of rare chalk grassland on the site which CCOrg will seek to regenerate. CCOrg is committed to delivering a small number of low impact houses, if appropriate, once the area’s ecological decline is stabilised. CCOrg intends to complement local nature recovery networks as a priority given the haven the site offers to both humans and wildlife from the surrounding encroachment of intensive development. CCOrg welcomes the opportunity to enable the community and BHCC to work together to explore a holistic approach to the city’s land and human’s relation to it, with an exemplar nature-led community project that can link the city back to Stanmer and the SDNP beyond, embracing the social value and volunteer workforce that this would bring.

Deciding to end the partnership has not been easy for any of us and, despite our differences in approach, both organisations feel that the opportunities presented to CLH by site 21(a) and (c) should not be missed to do things in a forward-thinking, sensitive, and locally appropriate way.